The Mastercraft Stratus A/S tires receive mixed reviews, with opinions varying widely on their performance and value.
The Mastercraft Stratus A/S tires appear to be a budget-friendly option with varying performance. While many users praise their handling and ride quality, especially in dry conditions, there are significant concerns about wet weather performance and tread life. The tires seem to perform better in some climates than others, with mixed results in rainy areas.
Positive highlights
Good handling on both wet and dry roads. Smooth and steady ride quality. Excellent traction in various weather conditions, including rain and snow. Affordable price point. Made in the USA.
Negative highlights
Some users experienced poor performance in wet conditions, with reports of spinning and slipping. Rapid tread wear reported by some customers. A few reports of deflation and broken belts. Reduced gas mileage in some cases.
Scorecard
Dry
4.8
Wet
4.5
Winter
3.9
Comfort
4.6
Noise
4.4
Treadwear
4.3
34 SimpleTire reviews
Nick
4.5
Honda Civic 2015 EX
Verified Customer
Mar 18, 2025
Great tire value
Amazing tire for the price, couldn't ask for anything better at the price point.
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
4
Winter
4
Comfort
4
Noise
4
Treadwear
5
Antonio
5
Volkswagen CC 2013 Lux
Verified Customer
Nov 7, 2024
I when
When I need tires I don't buy used I get the best from simpletireshop.com
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
5
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
5
M
4
Buick LaCrosse 2008 CX
Verified Customer
Nov 4, 2024
Quiet ride but wears quickly. Priced fairly.
Got these for an 08 Buick Lacrosse and they worked well for a passenger car. Dry performance great, and decent in the rain when new. Very quiet. Tread is kinda shallow and wears quickly. Rain performance degraded as that happened. Starting to hydroplane a bit at 40k miles. These are warranted for 50k but I think that might be asking a bit much of this tire. They're not bad for the price, but I'm going to something with a better weather rating and deeper tread for Florida.
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires30k+
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
3
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
3
Robert
2.5
Tesla Model 3 2020 Long Range
Verified Customer
Nov 28, 2023
Only good on perfect dry weather conditions
This tire is OK with gripping when it's dry and sunny out. But once the rain comes out or there's even a fleck of snow things start to change. Constantly slip in winter and rain and they provide zero stability when conditions aren't perfect.
Would you buy again?No
Miles driven on tires15k - 19k
Scorecard
Dry
4
Wet
1
Winter
1
Comfort
3
Noise
3
Treadwear
3
M
2.5
Nissan LEAF 2017 S
Verified Customer
Sep 1, 2023
Not for wet roads
I live in Portland, OR. These tires are some of the worst tires I have ever owned. Spinning out consistently in wet conditions, even if I am easy on the gas pedal. Borderline dangerous... Threw away after one season. They might be a good tire for dry climates, but I'd stay away from them if you live anywhere where rain is part of your daily driving.
Would you buy again?No
Miles driven on tires10k - 14k
Scorecard
Dry
3
Wet
1
Winter
1
Comfort
3
Noise
3
Treadwear
3
Rocko
5
Ford Escape 2018 Titanium
Verified Customer
Aug 19, 2023
Great all around tire.
The cost was on point as well. I purchased the warranty and Simple tire came through in that way as well when one of them was damaged by a road hazard. They stand behind the product, sell a great product and keep it simple. This is my third set of tires through this company and we are sticking with them.
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires15k - 19k
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
4
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
5
Edward
3.5
Subaru Forester 2015 2.5i Limited
Verified Customer
Jul 3, 2023
Not new, but not to warranty spec
I received these tires in November of 2019. Due to the pandemic, did not put on as many miles as I normally would. After 23,000 miles, my dealer was warning me to consider replacing them. I'm about 26,000 miles now and these are really too dangerous to use during heavy rain. Tread wear has been very disappointing. Admittedly, I have not rotated as I should (I've rotated 2-3 times since purchase), but no matter. All 4 require replacing. Will not buy again.
Would you buy again?No
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Scorecard
Dry
4
Wet
4
Winter
4
Comfort
4
Noise
4
Treadwear
2
Brian
1
Chrysler Town & 30th-anniversary-edition
Verified Customer
Jun 14, 2023
Do not order from Simple Tire
I've bought 3-4 sets of tires in the past with no issue. However, they have cancelled my last 2 orders and refuse to respond to my emails. Simple tire apparently made mistakes and listed several tires the wrong price. Instead of admit they screwed up, they'd rather just cancel orders and ghost customers.
Would you buy again?No
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Scorecard
Dry
1
Wet
1
Winter
1
Comfort
1
Noise
1
Treadwear
1
Mike
3.5
Buick Park Avenue 1994 Base
Verified Customer
Apr 11, 2022
Tires ride nice and priced great
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Scorecard
Dry
4
Wet
4
Winter
3
Comfort
3
Noise
3
Treadwear
3
44ND
3
Volkswagen Jetta 2009 TDI Sedan
Verified Customer
Feb 2, 2022
After putting on 20k miles, the tread is at 20%. Not happy with the wear on these. Overall an ok tire in North Dakota.
An all-season tire, Mastercraft's Stratus A/S is designed for use on sedans and CUVs and offers drivers good traction along with a 50,000 mile limited tread life warranty.
Features & Benefits
All-season tread
Black sidewall
50,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty
Deep, lateral shoulder slots consistently provide excellent traction throughout the life of the tire
Finding a set of tires that performs year round and lasts is a most for most drivers. Consider the Stratus A/S from Mastercraft, which features an advanced all season tread compound that enhances traction in wet, dry, and wintery conditions. Deep lateral shoulder slots ensure traction throughout the tire's lifespan, and the Stratus A/S also features shoulder sipe technology that provides more biting edges to strengthen all weather performance. Built with a solid center rib to give drivers a smooth ride, the Stratus A/S features a computer designed tread to reduce road noises so that drivers receive a quiet, comfortable ride.
Have a question about Mastercraft Stratus A/S tires?
Mastercraft Stratus A/S tires are made by the Cooper Tire & Rubber Company.
Yes, Mastercraft Stratus A/S tires are as good as Cooper branded tires. With the same parent company, Stratus A/S tires are designed to deliver the same performance and lifespan as Cooper products.
No, Mastercraft Stratus A/S tires are not manufactured in China. Stratus A/S tires are manufactured in North America, Latin America, Europe and Asia.
Yes, the tread design and casing of the Mastercraft Stratus A/S are computer tuned for low road noise.
Mastercraft Stratus A/S tires are backed by a 50,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. This means the Stratus A/S is expected to last at least 50,000 miles assuming proper use, maintenance, and rotation are followed.
Yes, the Mastercraft Stratus A/S can be used year-round thanks to its all-season rubber compound, shoulder sipes, and wide grooves that allow for conistent traction in dry, wet, and light winter weather conditions. The Stratus A/S is not Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified, so it should not be used in moderate to severe winter weather conditions.
Yes, the Mastercraft Stratus A/S features a continuous center rib and a spiral-wrapped nylon cord layer to boost straight-line stability at highway speed.
Yes, the Mastercraft Stratus A/S is available in a wide range of sizes for use on sedans, coupes, minivans and crossovers.