The Carlstar AT489 tires, designed for ATVs and off-road use, generally receive positive feedback from customers for their performance and durability.
The Carlstar AT489 tires are highly regarded for their versatility and durability in off-road applications. They perform well across various terrains and weather conditions, making them suitable for both work and recreational use on ATVs, side-by-sides, and farm equipment. While there were a few isolated issues, the majority of users are satisfied with the tires' performance and value.
Positive highlights
Excellent performance in various terrains and weather conditions. Good traction, especially in snow. Long-lasting durability, with some users reporting 10+ years of use. Comfortable ride quality, even with aggressive tread. Suitable for daily use on farm equipment and recreational vehicles. Good value for the price.
Negative highlights
One instance of receiving incorrect tire size.
Scorecard
Dry
4.8
Wet
4.8
Winter
4.6
Comfort
4.7
Noise
4.6
Treadwear
4.4
26 SimpleTire reviews
Patrick Usher,
4.5
Verified Customer
Oct 30, 2021
Would you buy again?No
Miles driven on tires15k - 19k
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
5
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
3
Patrick Usher,
4.5
Verified Customer
Oct 30, 2021
Would you buy again?No
Miles driven on tires15k - 19k
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
5
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
3
Tim
5
Verified Customer
Aug 18, 2020
Great tires great price.Quick delivery. Thanks
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Driving habitAggressive
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
5
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
5
William
4.5
Verified Customer
Aug 16, 2020
Really like the way the tires ride on rough roads
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Driving habitConfident
Scorecard
Dry
4
Wet
4
Winter
4
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
4
Joseph
4.5
Verified Customer
Aug 9, 2020
I just purchased these tires a couple of months ago, so I cant comment on tread wear or winter effect.
I have been pleasantly surprised by the sound and comfort of ride, because these tires are more aggressive than the ones I replaced.
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Driving habitConfident
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
4
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
4
Michael
5
Verified Customer
Aug 5, 2020
Great tires! Easy and smooth transition. Very fast shipping! I will definitely order from here again!
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Driving habitAggressive
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
5
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
5
george
5
Verified Customer
Jul 28, 2020
Quick delivery.
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Driving habitConfident
Scorecard
Dry
5
Wet
5
Winter
5
Comfort
5
Noise
5
Treadwear
5
Christopher
3.5
Verified Customer
Jul 27, 2020
Would you buy again?Yes
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Driving habitAggressive
Scorecard
Dry
4
Wet
4
Winter
3
Comfort
4
Noise
4
Treadwear
3
Larry
2.5
Verified Customer
Jul 19, 2020
Would you buy again?No
Miles driven on tires5k - 9k
Driving habitConfident
Scorecard
Dry
3
Wet
3
Winter
2
Comfort
3
Noise
3
Treadwear
2
M
5
Verified Customer
Jun 1, 2020
Great side by side tires. Great pricing. Great service from Simple Tire. I also just got a hard to find car tire from Simple Tire in just two days.
Versatility is a priority with the Carlstar/Carlisle AT489, as this ATV and UTV tire features a directional self-cleaning tread that's designed for reliable traction on a variety of surfaces, with low inflation pressure for a great ride and enhanced grip, plus a durable casing that holds up in rough use.
Features & Benefits
Designed for use on ATVs and UTVs
Able to be used on a variety of terrains
Directional tread pattern enhances traction and performance by promoting self-cleaning
Durable, damage resistant casing protects the tire from damage for a longer tread life
Able to be used at low inflation pressure to improve ride comfort
Carlisle branded tires are now Carlstar, and offer the same excellent performance, durability, and value that they have for the past 100 years